How Home Minister Rajnath Singh consolidating India’s Kashmir Policy
Soon after terrorist attack, Home Minister responded on Social Media while invoking the spirit of ‘Kashmiriyat’. Was it on continuity with India’s policy? or Is it a new turn being taken the government of India? The following analysis has explained it with independent observations.
Bharat Raut writes about this careful response in Free Press Journal. Raut terms it as ‘Rightful Restrain’. He praises Home Minister Rajnath Singh for taking the lead on the matter which was subsequently followed the state government and civil society in Jammu and Kashmir, followed. This gesture of maturity needs to be applauded all as that is the need of the hour. He further writes, Rajnath Singh spoke of Kashmiriyat immediately after the incidence. He did that because he believed that at this hour India, and all Indians, must speak as one. This attempt of invoking Kashmiriyat was not to appease anyone or any community. Home Minister realises, that the way forward is through reconciliation and not confrontation, through collective action and not isolation, through standing together as one people and not through segregation. This attitude is going to be gainful in the long run.
Wajahat Habibullah, former chairperson of the National Commission for Minorities has also asserted the need of united effort from the people of India in his article published in the Indian Express. By Amarnath Yatra attack, terrorists planned to create communal divisions among the people of Kashmir, but contrary to their expectations Kashmiri people protested against this heinous act. He explained the origin of ‘Kashmiriyat’ and its essence in common heritage of Hindu and Sufi traditions.
Tahir Syeed in Greater Kashmir has underlined the harmony in Kashmir and has termed it as victory of Kashmir. Quoting famous Urdu poet Narayan Chakbast, he writes about the great tradition of hospitability of the people of Kashmir. He found that section of media and some politicians tried to create communal divide after Amarnath attack. He has also pulled up Omar Abdullah for doing scare mongering against Kashmiris living outside Kashmir. He further finds that people of Kashmir believe in harmony and togetherness. Kashmiris proved what they stand for peace and brotherhood. Kashmiriyat won.
Harsha Kakar, retired Major-General of the Indian Army writes in The Statesman that Amarnath Yatra is the pilgrimage that builds the communal bridges in Kashmir. He takes note of the candle light vigil in Srinagar in protest of attack on Amarnath Yatri. This vigil proves that the majority of Kashmiri are not against the state. It is only the very few individuals, instigated pro-Pak separatists or terrorists who seek to target the pilgrims. He further explains that Amanath Yatra is a part of the national calendar for the government, as people from across the country participate in it. It is an indicator of the government’s determination to support the religious diversity of the nation even in remote and troubled areas. He finds that attack on Yatra was aimed to cared communal division in the country, but common Kashmiri and rest of the nation should never let terrorist succeed. He concludes that India will remain united despite these attacks owing to the harmony in our society.
Opposite to these observations, noted communist leader Brinda Karat writes in NDTV that Modi government has turned its back on Kashmir. She quotes Atal Bihari Vajpayee-ji’s speech in 2002. “For us, Kashmir is not a piece of land…it is a test case of secularism. India has always withstood the test of a secular nation. Jammu and Kashmir is a living example of this.” She blames the central government and BJP for promoting nationalism, Hindu nationalism that make Kashmiri as soft target. At same time, she praises Home Minister of India, Shri Rajnath Singh for his Kashmiriayat stance. She writes, shri Singh has reiterated that the job of his ministry is to maintain harmony.
It is also important to take a note of Kashmiri researcher’s media article on the matter, as it would reflect different perspective. This article “Terror attack on Amarnath Pilgrims and beyond” is written Dr. Fayaz Ahmad Bhat in Daily Kashmir Images. In this article, he tried to develop a conspiracy theory around this terrorist attack and indirectly blames ruling BJP party for it. His point of views are on line of separatists and asserts the resolutions International Organisation of Islamic States, Amnesty International, Iran, China etc all has denounced India for its Kashmir policy. He mischievously drops Pakistan’s name in this list. He tries to justify that Kashmiri terrorism is not Islamic terrorism. This social activist and faculty member at the Dept of Sociology, University of Jammu and Kashmir, totally ignores the statement of Home Minister Rajnath Singh and concludes, “BJP does seem to be on a mission of demolition: to demolish Ganaga- Jamuni Tahzeeb (culture) of India, to demolish brotherhood, peace, communal harmony and above all Kashmiriyat.”
The idea of Kashmiriyat put forth Home Minister Shri Rajnath Singh is taken as a concept of harmony and peace. It has exhibited that government of India has faith in people of Kashmir. The terrorists needs to be cornered socially, hence the citizen outreach programs can be planned on this line. Some separatist minded scholars, being hired in state universities needs clear messages on the policy and the official stand of the government. They should not be allowed to produce fresh batches of terrorist sympathizes and stone pelters. However, with current approach of the central government, terrorists are being corners socially and politically. The social fabric of Kashmir essentially consist of Kashmiri pundits, the government should address their settlement using the spirit of Kashmiriyat as it is perceived as common cultural heritage.
Interested in internal and external security of India. Security Analyst, Diplomacy Scholar, #CyberSecurity and #FinancialSecurity expert.

